Girl, What? Jay-Z’s False Accuser Targets Supporters

It’s safe to say that Jane Doe’s false allegations against Mr. Carter didn’t just bruise egos—they tore open centuries-old wounds still festering in America’s social fabric. Wounds that have long been the backdrop for racially motivated violence, systemic persecution, and the relentless destruction of Black families, businesses, and communities.

@JulioCortez

The blueprint is chillingly familiar. We’ve seen it in history’s ugliest chapters:

• Carolyn Bryant Donham’s infamous lie, which led to the brutal murder of 14-year-old Emmett Till from Chicago.

• Irene Tusken and James Sullivan’s lie in Duluth, Minnesota, which resulted in the savage beating of nine Black migrant laborers, the public hanging of six, and the burning alive of three more.

• Fannie Taylor’s lie, which sparked the obliteration of the prosperous Black town of Rosewood, Florida.

• George Zimmerman’s targeted pursuit and murder of Trayvon Martin, a tragedy that reignited the modern equity movement—yet Zimmerman went on to commit multiple violent offenses, including domestic violence.

• Kenneth Lilly, whose protected identity after the murder of 16-year-old Lavauntai Broadbent during a prank in which Lilly was not convicted of murder, allowed Lilly to later open fire on a moving school bus with children aboard in which he was charged with attempted murder for injuring the white bus driver.

And let’s not forget every "Karen" and "Ken" who callously weaponize the criminal justice system against innocent Black children, women, and men—triggering police violence, unjust incarcerations, and lifelong trauma, while the nation reduces their violence to viral memes. These perpetrators are conditioned by a society that tells them Black people are easy, permissible targets—enabled by media, courts, and law enforcement systems that shield and validate their hate, rather than holding them accountable.

Now, Jane Doe is continuing that ugly legacy. In support of her defense, she submitted an affidavit in the Los Angeles case making new allegations. Jane Doe—whose identity remains protected by the courts—claims that two individuals identifying themselves as investigators working with Mr. Carter’s attorney approached her at her home, pressuring her to recant her story. She asserts she refused.

Additionally, she alleges she withdrew her lawsuit not because her claims lacked merit, but out of fear—claiming concern over public backlash and threats from Jay-Z’s supporters.

But here’s the truth: there is no specific allegation, no verified incident, no shred of evidence that Jane Doe has faced a single threat or backlash from supporters of Mr. Carter. Not one.

Yet still, she is allowed to anonymously lob accusations while protected by the very justice system that should hold false claims to account.

The reality is, America has rarely protected Black excellence; instead, it has far too often targeted it. That’s why many Black Americans, quietly but firmly, rally behind figures like Mr. Carter and Cardi B—who famously sued blogger Tasha K for $3 million—when they stand up against lies, brutality, and smear campaigns. Not because of celebrity status, but because they wield their platforms to set precedents and send a message: the days of unchecked targeting are numbered.

Every American deserves peace, safety, and the right to be judged by their actions—not malicious lies. Every person, regardless of skin color, deserves to keep what they’ve worked for without fearing it will be torn apart by anyone greedy, unstable, or hateful enough to call their number. But until this country fully reckons with its past and present—until it holds accountable those who falsely accuse, fabricate, and fuel anti-Black violence—Black people will continue to defend those who resist, expose, and refuse to be destroyed.

WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE INSIDER ARTICLES LIKE THIS? TAKE THE POLL